The Manager Who Thought He Could Create a Community

Artist Liz Wolfe
Artist Liz Wolfe

A strange behavior of managers is their urge to manage everything. Designing social media or creating communities are examples of a certain way of thinking. This post by Matt Simpson made me once more aware that with regard to the social web as a manager and professional I have to adapt. And I have to accept that most crowds not can be created!

Post found at

By Matt Simpson through

In my practice, I see many people who are tackling challenges within the collaborative process.  Frequently people want to work with communities, yet are struggling with one aspect or another.

I had a meeting today with a manager who thought he could create a community.  He was troubled that the community didn’t really work well.  It really made him angry.


Now, you might ask yourself, how in the world can a man create a community?  Aren’t communities made of people?  Aren’t they voluntary?  Don’t they form when people gather together and interact with one another voluntarily based on something they have in common and actually recognize themselves as members of a persistent group?  Yes, of course.

So, I asked the man, how did he do it?  He showed me.

As I watched over his shoulder, he did the most amazing thing.  He opened his laptop, sat down at the keyboard, launched his browser, and went to a web site.  At the web site, he clicked a button, which launched a form.  After filling out the form and submitting it, the web page showed the name he had chosen for the community at the top of blank page.  He then clicked some more buttons and uploaded a file to the web site.  When I asked him what was in the file, he explained that it was a list of internet IDs.

This post is recommended for you  The secret to digital success? Design thinking

After the internet IDs were processed my this web application, he sat back, pointed at the screen, smiled, and proclaimed that he had just created a community, just like he had previously.  «Is this all you did?» I asked.  Of course, not, he explained.  He had also assigned someone to manage the community.  His major frustration was that the assigned community manager hadn’t taken his role seriously.

So, we talked a bit about the concept of communities… about voluntary membership and participation… about the self-selecting nature of the membership itself… about the need for leaders to self-select from within the membership and identify their own topics.  This is a typical flow of discussion, which, when given enough time and insight, eventually changes a person’s entire outlook… from manager to gardener.  Communities form and emerge naturally.  They can be encouraged and facilitated; But they can’t be engineered and determined.

A man can no more create a community by filling out a form on a webpage than he can make a fruit tree by taping fruit to twigs and twigs to a stump.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]